Islamorada Florida Keys

Endless Bay Views, Sue's Promise

A private beachfront villa where the Keys come alive

Welcome

Your Own Piece of Paradise

If you love open water views, nature, plants, wildlife, and the feeling of enjoying your own place by the sea — you will feel right at home at Sue’s Promise. Nestled on a stunning 1.5-acre property directly on the bay, our villas offer an intimate escape unlike any other in the Florida Keys.

High season brings guests seeking warmth and respite from the cold. Summer is all about fishing, lobstering, diving and countless water sports. With Pennekamp National Park and Dry Tortugas National Park nearby, adventure is always within reach.

Perfect for couples’ getaways, solo travellers, and families alike.

4.89 Guest Favourite

Photo Tour

Life at Sue's Promise

Why Sue's Promise

A Villa That Has Ite All

Unbeatable Location

100% of guests in the past year gave this location a 5-star rating. Directly on the bay with endless water views.

Beach & Bay Views

Private beach, dock, and jetty — all just steps from your door. Soak up the views morning to sunset.

Water Adventures

Fishing, lobstering, diving, snorkelling and more. The Florida Keys' best water sports are at your doorstep.

Complete Privacy

A maximum of 8 guests across both villas at any time. Your own shaded patio with outside propane grill and outdoor seating.

5-Star Hospitality

Hosts Charlie earn top marks for communication. They're present most weekends to ensure a perfect stay.

What's Included

Thoughtfully Appointed Amenities

Rest & Comfort

Where You'll Sleep

Master Bedroom

1 Queen Bed — A peaceful, beautifully appointed bedroom with natural light and serene tropical surroundings.

Living Room

1 optional queen size air bed — A versatile living space that doubles as sleeping for additional guests with full comfort.

Guest Experiences

What Guests Are Saying

4.89

53 Reviews

Cleanliness 98%

Accuracy 99%

Check-in 99%

Communication 99%

Location 100%

Value 98%

Sarah M.

January 2025

"Absolutely stunning property. Waking up to bay views every morning was something I'll never forget. Charlie were incredibly welcoming and made us feel completely at home."

James & Laura

March 2025

"The location is truly unbeatable. We spent every evening on the dock watching the sunset. The villa itself is well-equipped and immaculately clean. Would return in a heartbeat."

Sarah M.

February 2025

"Our family had the most incredible Keys experience. The private beach was our favorite spot, and the hosts went above and beyond to recommend local restaurants and activities."

Sarah M.

February 2025

"Our family had the most incredible Keys experience. The private beach was our favorite spot, and the hosts went above and beyond to recommend local restaurants and activities."

Guest Experiences

Islamorada, Florida Keys

Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Sue’s Promise sits directly on the bay in a quiet residential area of Islamorada — one of the most beautiful stretches of the Upper Keys. Our 1.5-acre property offers a peaceful haven while keeping you close to everything the Keys have to offer.

Our 1.5-acre property offers a peaceful haven while keeping you close to everything the Keys have to offer.

Robbie's Marina

~3 miles north

Bud n Mary's Marina

5 miles north

Lorelei & Lazy Days

5–6 miles north

Publix Supermarket

7 miles north

Pennekamp National Park

Nearby

Dry Tortugas National Park

Day trip

Your Hosts

Charlie

Reviews

4.89

Rating

Years Hosting

Charlie Gomes resides in Miami and the Florida Keys. Charlie is a practicing CPA and manages Sue’s Promise. He shares his life with two cocker spaniels, Barbie and Ken.

The owners are generally present on weekends to greet guests and ensure a wonderful stay. Response rate: 100% — typically responding within a day.